Thursday, April 14, 2011

Living in envy of Nashville

I just caught this snip from the CBC's Jeff Marek, host of Hockey Night in Canada Radio and the HNIC iDesk, relative to the Preds' first round, game one, 4-1 spanking of the Anaheim Ducks:
** Have to respect the Preds for exactly what they did last night against the Ducks: Stifled them at every turn. I won't bother to go over all the injuries and adversities that team has been through (we al know the drill) rather just focus on what it is they do with who they have. I spoke to former Pred Dan Hamhuis on our radio show the other day and he talked about how the Preds play systems in all areas of the ice. No matter where the puck is or who has it Nashville knows how to play. Also, next time you watch the Preds count how many players you see in your screen at any given time. In most situations you'll see at least 4 and often 5. They move as a 5 man unit and support each other all the way up and back down the ice. It helps, of course, when you have an all world netminder like Pekka Rinne and a defenseman like Shea Weber who hits like Scott Stevens and shoots like Al MacInnis.
I'll grant that Barry Trotz has had over 10 years to implement his system, and David Poile has had the same amount of time to get the people he needs to implement that system onto the Preds' roster. But gosh, wouldn't it be nice to be able to easily identify with a "Columbus system"? Not to deify Ken Hitchcock, but I think it was a lot easier to identify the Hitch system than the Arniel system.

Even after 82 games (and having watched easily 2/3 of them very, very closely), I'm still not sure I can explain what Arniel's system is all about. There are identifiable pieces, like defensemen who gamble by jumping into (or even leading) the offensive rush, or forwards who have to pass 12 times before shooting on a given rush. But I'm not sure what else there is, which is why I started to refer to the CBJ on-ice play as "Romper Room". Just a bunch of guys skating around, waiting for a random act of a puck going past a goalie.

Perhaps the real Arniel system (and Arniel-style players) will come with time. Until then, I'll just keep living in envy of what Poile and Trotz have created in Nashville.  With fewer salary dollars.

Tuesday, April 12, 2011

Calling all Blue Jackets fans

No, I'm not soliciting again for the 2011 Crowdsourced NHL Awards with this post.  But you're welcome to go vote, as voting is closed on Saturday night.

Nope, this time it's to solicit you to get involved with the NHL's feedback loop - the NHL Fan Face Off panel.

Should you choose to join this panel, you get access and influence with the NHL's decision-making.  Every now and then, you get an email from the league asking for your opinion about the topic du jour.  I've participated in surveys about the Winter Classic, television packages, Patrick Kane's mullet...OK, not that last one.  But I have been asked about matters of substance related to the NHL.

Apparently, the Columbus Blue Jackets fan representation on this panel is one of the lowest in the league.  They want to hear from you.  Go sign up and have your voice heard!

Out of Time: Thoughts on the talent pipeline

I intend to get to the Columbus Blue Jackets position analyses for the 2010-2011 season soon, but I thought that the next post in this series should address what I consider to be a critical strategic issue for the team.

Despite the suggestions that they have addressed a main problem of the Doug MacLean era, that of rushing young players into the NHL too quickly with too little preparation, the roster doesn't lie:
  • Derick Brassard, 23 - 3rd "full" season with Columbus (1 of the 3 cut short due to injury)
  • Matt Calvert, 21 - 1st season in Columbus  (I don't think anyone sees him returning to Springfield)
  • Jakub Voracek, 21 - 3rd season in Columbus
  • Kris Russell, 23 - 4th season in Columbus
  • Steve Mason, 22 - 3rd season in Columbus
Has experience not been instructive?  Of the many CBJ draftees since the inception of the franchise, it can be argued that only Rick Nash was able to handle the jump from the draft (and juniors) to the NHL without meaningful time in the minors.

Monday, April 11, 2011

Demolition Experts

Well folks, the DBJ has dropped the gloves, calling for blowing up the CBJ roster.  In my role as executive optimist, I am supposed to provide counterpoint to this opinion.  But putting lipstick on this pig won't make it any more attractive, it's still a pig. 

So some things to consider in this discussion.

When we look at the Nashville Predators (congrats to the folks in Nashville) the stark difference between the two franchises is stability.  Same coach, same general manager since day one.  They are on Vision Version 1.  We are on at least Vision 3, realistically probably Vision 3.2.2.  You can't retool overnight to reach these conflicting/contradictory visions.  At some point in the life of this franchise, you need some stability.  Especially to attract the top notch free agents.  Howson's approach to providing a modicum of stability did not turn out well.  In fact, it turned out to be surprisingly (or not so surprisingly) similar. 

Out of Time: DBJ's 2010-2011 Columbus Blue Jackets review

"What have you guys been doing for 10 years?"
- Columbus Blue Jackets head coach Scott Arniel
after coaching the CBJ to their first-ever regulation win in San Jose
November 21, 2010

That's a very, very good question.  Sadly, the answer is: One brief playoff appearance.

I observed way back at the beginning of the season that general manager Scott Howson cleared out so many able veterans from that 2009 Blue Jackets playoff team to make room on the CBJ roster for his vaunted young core.  This team has had 82 games to prove their worthiness as an NHL-caliber roster.  Here's what we got:
  • They gave new head coach Scott Arniel an incredible 20-game honeymoon with a 14-6-0 record.  Who can forget perhaps one of the greatest CBJ games ever, the 8-1 shellacking of the St. Louis Blues in Game 14 on November 10th?  This team was challenging for first place in the Western Conference over Thanksgiving weekend.  
  • They then fell flat on their faces from Thanksgiving through mid-January with a 6-14-3 record.
  • Howson made roster improvements by subtraction in sending $3.75 million veteran defenseman Mike Commodore down to AHL Springfield, but the subsequent rebound (11-4-3) only could take the team to the trade deadline.  
  • The team maxxed out, and the wheels flew off throughout March and April, highlighted by a 3-11-7 record (and 1-6-3 at home!) to close out the season.
That, my friends, was the second-best season in team's ten-year history.  Wow.

The questions that never get asked

The Dispatch takes a swing at a season-wrapup interview with Columbus Blue Jackets general manager Scott Howson, and it goes about as well as could be expected for a team that underachieved and a general manager who graduated from law school.

Interviews like this are somewhat tough.  It was conducted by a beat writer in between periods of the final game of the season against Buffalo.  Not exactly ideal conditions to probe the many "WTF?" questions facing this franchise.  There was lots of other activity going on, deadlines to meet, etc.  So I'll give the Dispatch a pass on this one.

For my money, the softballs tossed at Howson by Fox Sports Ohio revealed more interesting responses.  (And wouldn't you know, FSO didn't post the interview on their website.  Come on, FSO - you have good content on your broadcasts...post it for people to watch after the game is over!)

Regardless,  I still have yet to hear anyone ask Howson two simple, open-ended questions that could provide context and insight to everything that Howson does as the personnel "ninja" for the team:
  1. Describe your ideal NHL team, specifically with regards to style of play and roster composition.
  2. Assess the current Blue Jackets roster against that ideal.
It's not rocket science.  I want to know Howson's vision.  To date, no one has asked him what that vision is.  Without that understanding, how can we appreciate anything that he's doing to improve the club?

Heck, I'll even take just the first question.  Get me a straight answer to that, and I'll do the math on the CBJ roster side of things.

It's moments like these that I almost wish I had media credentials...just to ask the questions that are crying out to be asked.

Sunday, April 10, 2011

2011 Crowdsourced NHL Awards - Voting is Open!

The nominations are closed, and the voting for the 2011 Crowdsourced NHL Awards are open!

Swing on over to the Facebook page and make your selections for Hart, Vezina, Norris, Calder, Selke and Lady Byng trophies.  (Maybe another?  I can't remember...)

It's all in fun, so make sure to vote and tell your friends to do so, too!

Boston Globe assessment of the CBJ season

With a hat tip to Kukla's Corner for pointing this article out, here's Boston Globe writer Kevin Paul Dupont's take on the Columbus Blue Jackets as they currently stand:
Columbus — The Blue Jackets [did not qualify for the playoffs] for a second straight season, not so bad in itself, at least outside of Canada. But that quick visit to the postseason in ’09 (a sweep by the Red Wings) stands as their only playoff time in 10 seasons. General manager Scott Howson has been on the job four seasons and really hasn’t moved the meter much beyond where Doug MacLean had it when sacked after the 2006-07 season. Hockey can work in Columbus, and the Jackets have one of the league’s best buildings (with accompanying practice facility), but after 824 games and only one season with more wins than losses, it has turned into a hockey horror flick.
We can quibble about how the talent pipeline is a little better, and how MacLean left such a mess, but I'm not sure I can argue with the conclusions.

Saturday, April 9, 2011

Game 82/Buffalo: My Take

The Columbus Blue Jackets closed out the 2010-2011 NHL season, their 10th in the league, with a 5-4 loss to the Buffalo Sabres in regulation at Nationwide Arena.

No more cannons firing.  No more "No way but the hard way."  No more Leo.  No more "Goal scorers goals."  No more "Gotta See It Live!"  That's it until the 2011-2012 preseason starts up in September.

One year ago

Roughly one year ago, Rick Nash took out an ad in the Columbus Dispatch and gave us this:


As we stand of the cusp of the offseason, it might be worth asking: What's he going to say this time around?